RailForum.com
TrainWeb.com

RAILforum Post A Reply
my profile | directory login | register | search | faq | forum home

» RAILforum » Passenger Trains » Amtrak » Ideas for Amtrak » Post A Reply

Post A Reply
Login Name:
Password:
Message Icon: Icon 1     Icon 2     Icon 3     Icon 4     Icon 5     Icon 6     Icon 7    
Icon 8     Icon 9     Icon 10     Icon 11     Icon 12     Icon 13     Icon 14    
Message:

HTML is not enabled.
UBB Code™ is enabled.

 

Instant Graemlins Instant UBB Code™
Smile   Frown   Embarrassed   Big Grin   Wink   Razz  
Cool   Roll Eyes   Mad   Eek!   Confused    
Insert URL Hyperlink - UBB Code™   Insert Email Address - UBB Code™
Bold - UBB Code™   Italics - UBB Code™
Quote - UBB Code™   Code Tag - UBB Code™
List Start - UBB Code™   List Item - UBB Code™
List End - UBB Code™   Image - UBB Code™

What is UBB Code™?
Options


Disable Graemlins in this post.


 


T O P I C     R E V I E W
canoe86
Member # 3099
 - posted
There has been a lot of discussion about the future of Amtrak on this board lately. Instead of just thinking about subsidies etc., how about some ideas that will make Amtrak better.

How about if Amtrak created a new sleeper car with bigger accomadations. This would take care of the big families (of which many have posted here lately). Plus, they could add some features that would allow for a higher ticket price. If you took a sleeper and took out the standard rooms, and just had large deluxe type room that could sleep, 5-6 with their own bathroom. Also include things like a TV and DVD/VCR capabilities. Maybe a working radio that you could tune into stations as you travel. Both of these would be low cost features that would be nice additions. I think you could easily charge more for these rooms. Plus the extra room would generate a higher ticket price AND it would bring in families AND make the trip a bit nicer.

Just a thought, any others?
 

jimdim8151
Member # 3592
 - posted
It's hard for me to comment since my 1st Amtrak trip is only 6 days away (but who's counting?)

I guess it's the old "it takes money to make money" idea, but without funding I don't see how Amtrak can really do much to improve their accomodations and equipment in the ways you suggest.

Just my thoughts.

Jim D.
 

Big Merl
Member # 3251
 - posted
I'll bring in my idea again about an overnight class car feature 2-1 seating with 180 degree reclining seats. I'll also toss out again my idea about a single level sightseer lounge.

A new idea I have had recently is to bring the airline style overhead bins to Amtrack, which I'm sure some of the short haul trains already have. It would clean up the look of coach a little. Maybe during the install they can include some power plugs too
 
Charles Reuben
Member # 2263
 - posted
Amtrak is going down the tubes and you guys are thinking about enlarging the bedrooms in the sleeper cars?

Bigger bedrooms are not going to save Amtrak. The trains are already running near capacity and if they getting any more popular, Amtrak will have a huge problem.

Big Merl, I think you have a good idea about fully reclined seating and I'm curious to know if you are aware of anybody out there that has actually pulled this off (except Virgin Airlines).

Fully reclined seating, or at least more ergonomic seating (like those found on the Surfliner) might enhance Amtrak's appeal to the masses.

In the past I have asked the board whether Sleeper cars were a financial burdon to Amtrak's bottom line, but got no response. Having just bought into my first long-distance sleeper, my initial impression is that they look pretty pricey to maintain.

I wonder if there might not be some sort of economically viable middle road between sleepers and coach.

[This message has been edited by Chucky (edited 02-09-2005).]
 

iowamomofsix
Member # 3695
 - posted
Maybe renovating the cars of the train isn't the answer. I still think they could do some things to work smarter instead of harder, for instance, doing some more public relations work. For instance, I think it would be helpful for Amtrak to set up regional web sites and linking their stations page to them with information, like airports do on rental car locations, shuttle companies that can transport for airport to train station transfers, and food locations. They could also work with whoever it must be to contract secure parking, open up mini food courts, or snack machines in the smaller stations, and entice rental car companies to locate closer to them like they do at the airports.

In planning our trips, dh wants to fly because he's concerned about spending two days straight on the train, especially with our brood, even with a sleeper.

However, he'd like to fly to Portland, or San Francisco and take the one of the coastal trains to LA. But not knowing what to expect by way of a connection from airline to train is enough fo us to resign to flying.

I'm a genealogist. In my world of genealogy, any of us who want to get information online has to fork out $200 per year in subscription to get most information from the web.

However, a national community of genealogist have set up a very extensive information network for each state, county, and city, where volunteers maintain a web site for each locality with information on local libraries, where to get vital records, and donated records. The volunteer effort has helped us beat the system.

Maybe we could help Amtrak, and I know some already have, this site being the proof, by setting up "official" insider web sites for each station.

If I could find a safe and economical way to transfer my family from the airport in any of the following cities, KC, Denver, Salt Lake, Reno, Oakland, LA, Albuquerque, Fullerton, Portland, Seattle, my dh would consider taking a portion of our trip on the train each way.

Speaking for families, we want to know how to get to the nearest hotel at midnight after we just got off the train. We want to know if the city we will be dropped off is a walking city, like Chicago, or watch- your-back-city like KC. We want to know if we need to pack a snack on the way because, like Omaha, there are only expensive yuppy restaurants nearby, or if we can rely on McDonald's when we get there. Is there a museum at the station like KC and Omaha? Is the station big, seating comfortable, or is the station open for just minutes a day with car being left to the mercy of whoever walks by while you are gone. If so, is their a parking structure within walking distance? I know some have maintained web sites with some of this information, but information would best service us if it was linked to one major Internet hub, like USGENWEB.ORG, where you can go to a national site and click on links to individual stations.

It seems to me, Amtrak is so stretched they don't even have time to be an information bureau. The information they provide on their web site, while contains a lot of information, is quite scanty when it comes to the particulars we need to feel brave enough to go on the train. We need more how-to's

Contrast that with the airlines....yesterday I was able to find at the Omaha airport, where the parking was located, the parking charge, the shuttles that service the airport, the airlines that service, the weather, restaurants in the airport, points of interest nearby, and hotels.

Well, at least it would be a inexpensive enhancement that couldn't hurt. Especially, if it were a community effort run by Amtrak fans.

I'm definitely not an expert on train riding. Never been on one, but I certainly know what the hurdles are from keeping me from taking my first train ride.

And as always, I know I'm ignorant, so if this is just a bunch of "hot air" have a good laugh and take it with a grain of salt.

Thanks,

Debbie (trying somehow to get on that train!)
 

Gilbert B Norman
Member # 1541
 - posted
Naturally, in response to Mr. Reuben's suggestion, what first comes to mind is some kind of economy Sleeper arrangement.

There was only one successful economy sleeper out there and that was the Budd Slumbercoach which Amtrak eventually acquired the entire fleet of those built new during the "mid-fifties' as well as many ex NYC "conversions".

The only reason the Slumbercoach was a success, both with public acceptance and with operational economies was that it represented a breakthrough in Sleeper capacity. The ubiquitous 10-6 slept 22; the 24-8 Slumbercoach 40.

I think two things doomed the Slumbercoach on Amtrak. First was the oft reported need to convert all cars to retention toilets; the myriad of plumbing arising from the duplex arrangement would have made such economically unfeasable.

A second reason was Amtrak's ability to implement demand pricing resulting constantly changing accomodation charges to reflect anticipated demand on any train. Railroads were regulated; this is the price we charge - period. Even if we wanted to change it, we would have to jump through regulatory 'hoops' to do so. Amtrak was deregulated on A-Day, but the perfection of information systems, even on airlines, was hardly in place.

Amtrak can simply accomplish the same purpose using its existing configurations for the present and hopefully some day expanded fleet and offer reduced rate sleeper accomodations away from the peak travel periods.

In short Economy sleeper cars were made obsolete by the computer.
 

Charles Reuben
Member # 2263
 - posted
Mr. Norman,

I couldn't find any layouts of the slumbercoach, but I did find a nice shot of the exterior:
http://home.att.net/~jtbradley/amtk2021.html

I don't understand why they need elaborate plumbing for a crapper. It just breaks down in the end. Thanks for insight into a bygone era.

Debbie,

I had a memorable experience with a Morman during the New Mexico State Fair. She logged on to Ancestry.com and located the handwritten 1930's census report for father's family. It sent shivers up and down my spine. The extraordinary thing was that she found it, even though the census taker had misspelled our last name. You guys are good.

I recommend stopping in Albuquerque for your train adventure. The station is now located in the old gift shop of the Alvarado Hotel, which was torn down in the 70's. It's a crumby station, but its better than nothing, I suppose.

A couple blocks away is the La Posada Hotel, the first hotel built by Conrad Hilton. It has a lot of Old World charm and the elevators move at a nice clip. It has a nicely restored lobby and I think you will find the rates affordable. East of La Posada is a place called Maisel's where you can buy Indian pots for a fraction of the price you would pay elsewhere. Some of it is quite good.

La Posada has a van that can transport your brood from the station to the Hotel and from the Hotel to our International Airport.

Albuquerque is probably as safe as anywhere, I would think. I have lived here (in the Old Town area) for over 20 years and I've never had any trouble. But then, I don't go looking for trouble, either.

You can take a restored trolley from the ATC (Albuquerque Transit Center) to Old Town where your kids can frolic at the Children's Museum. Then you can check out the Natural History Museum as well as our beautiful crown jewel, the Albuquerque Museum.

A little ways up Central ave from Old Highway 66 is our aquarium and botanical gardens, also worth seeing.

I suppose I should give a plug for the Atomic Museum in Old Town as well, but I'm really quite pissed at them for erecting a 60 foot missile in front of their digs. It's not the missile concept that bugs me, I would have objected to a 60 foot dinosaur as well. Fact of the matter is, it just doesn't fit.

[This message has been edited by Chucky (edited 02-09-2005).]
 

iowamomofsix
Member # 3695
 - posted
That is so cool! That's why I like doing genealogy. Thanks for the suggestion. How far is it to the airport there, and are there any good transit options getting there from the hotel? Or do they have a free shuttle?

Thanks Chucky,

Debbie
 

TheBriz09
Member # 3166
 - posted
quote:
Originally posted by iowamomofsix:
Well, at least it would be a inexpensive enhancement that couldn't hurt. Especially, if it were a community effort run by Amtrak fans.

I'm definitely not an expert on train riding. Never been on one, but I certainly know what the hurdles are from keeping me from taking my first train ride.

And as always, I know I'm ignorant, so if this is just a bunch of "hot air" have a good laugh and take it with a grain of salt.



What Debbie said above sparked my interest, and I think it's quite the idea, if there's enough support to get it going. Why couldn't we get a volunteer website going with details like Debbie described? It would be a mammoth coordinating effort, but I think there are enough people on this board with the web know-how to do the coding and such (I could start), and I have no doubt that if everyone here contributed information, we could easily get pages going for all of the major stations and many other ones besides. It's a big dream, sure, but like Debbie says, it would begin to fill a big hole.

What's stopping us?

I think this idea at least warrants further conversation, if nothing else... if Debbie or anyone else wants to chat about the possibilities, definitely drop me a line at David-Breisch@augustana.edu. Or if anyone uses AOL Instant Messenger, my screenname is TheBriz09. I would love to hear from you.

- David
 

notelvis
Member # 3071
 - posted
quote:
Originally posted by iowamomofsix:
However, he'd like to fly to Portland, or San Francisco and take the one of the coastal trains to LA. But not knowing what to expect by way of a connection from airline to train is enough fo us to resign to flying.

If I could find a safe and economical way to transfer my family from the airport in any of the following cities, KC, Denver, Salt Lake, Reno, Oakland, LA, Albuquerque, Fullerton, Portland, Seattle, my dh would consider taking a portion of our trip on the train each way


Hey Debbie,

Here are some tips that I can offer from past trips and or research for getting from Airports to Rail Stations.

In San Francisco you can take BART. One or two stations from the airport there is a BART station and transfer point to the CalTran Commuter trains. Take the Commuter train south to San Jose and you can interface with the Amtrak system there.

In Portland the Max lightrail operates from the airport into downtown coming within just three blocks or so of the train station.

In St. Louis the light rail goes from the airport to Union Station which, sadly, is a four block dusty hike to where the Amtrak station is actually located.

If you go east, the BWI airport has direct light rail service to Penn Station in downtown Baltimore or a free shuttle bus to the BWI Rail Station.

In June 2002, fearing an imminent Amtrak shutdown, I made a trip to sample as many of the Amtrak routes that I don't have much of an opportunity to ride. As part of that trip I arrived via Amtrak in Albuquerque from Los Angeles (in coach Chucky!!!) and caught the city bus right next door to the airport. There was (and I assume still is) a route that got me right to the airport without having to change for just $1.00.......and the airport in Albuquerque is very close to downtown......maybe just three or four miles out.....unlike Denver or Kansas City. As Chucky will tell you, Albuquerque has some real advantages.

Denver does have bus service called SkyRide offered by the RTD. Takes 45 minutes or so and costs $8.00 per person one-way. Not cheap with a big family. The SkyRide bus gets you to the downtown transfer terminal on 16th street just a few blocks from Union Station. You can get the free downtown shuttle bus to the foot of 16th street which is only a block or so from Union Station.

Best wishes and Happy Travels.

------------------
David Pressley
 

Charles Reuben
Member # 2263
 - posted
The #50 bus goes directly from the airport to downtown Albuquerque and it costs $1 (for adults). If you stayed at La Posada, or any other major hotel, they would probably have a free van. Most hotels don't offer free rides around town, but as I said, if you stayed at La Posada, you would have easy access to the transit hub. See www.cabq.gov for schedules.

My brother-in-law is coming to visit me in Albuquerque and I can't get him to stay at the La Posada. Instead I fixed him up at an interesting place on a hill called Plaza Inn.

Although it is not in the middle of downtown, it is in a very lovely place, on a hill overlooking the city: http://www.plazainnabq.com/location.htm

The Plaza Inn appears to have a van driver that will not only take you to train/plane, but evidentally it will also drop you off in Old Town or Downtown. From there you can connect with public transit and get to wherever you like. There is actually a bus (the #11) that could conceivably drop you off within a block of your motel.

As far as the distance from downtown to the airport is concerned, I would say it is a good 10 or 15 miles. Certainly not a hop, skip or a jump. But easy by motorized vehicle, ever since we rebuilt our freeways.

[This message has been edited by Chucky (edited 02-09-2005).]
 

notelvis
Member # 3071
 - posted
quote:
Originally posted by Chucky:
from downtown to the airport is concerned, I would say it is a good 10 or 15 miles. Certainly not a hop, skip or a jump. But easy by motorized vehicle, ever since we rebuilt our freeways.

(edited 02-09-2005).]


Gee.......it seemed only half that distance at most. I guess I was just having such a pleasant ride on the Albuquerque bus.....clean, quiet, pleasant. And the Albuquerque Airport is one of the nicer airports I have been in too.

------------------
David Pressley
 

TwinStarRocket
Member # 2142
 - posted
Debbie:
Since ABQ is my most frequent (and favorite) jumping off point, I can add to what Chucky said. The cab ride is only about $12+tip to the airport and a 10-15 minute ride. If you rent a car from Hertz, they have a courtesy phone in the depot and will pay your cab ride to the airport for your pick-up. It is so quick I have left ABQ in my rental car before the #3 did, only to have it pass me as I drove down I-25. Then you may drop the car at the depot and leave the key and paperwork with the Amtrak agent. Cheaper auto rates than most cities.

The train is almost always on time or early at ABQ, due to padding. It is a beautiful, small and safe downtown with many attractions, and centrally located in a scenic state. Beautiful and easily accessable airport terminal too, easy to drive in and out of with no traffic.

I love your idea about all of us contributing to a website of Amtrak info! Having tried many stations west of CHI, and living in St. Paul near the depot, I could contribute much.

[This message has been edited by TwinStarRocket (edited 02-09-2005).]

[This message has been edited by TwinStarRocket (edited 02-09-2005).]
 

RRRICH
Member # 1418
 - posted
Hi Debbie! - this may be a bit off-topic, but for several years now I have been attempting to develop my own "travelogues" covering AMTRAK routes -- my guides are much better than the pamphlets they used to have on-board the trains, and my guides are tied into a set of topographic map guides I have put together over the years which contain DETAILED topographic maps of ALL the AMTRAK routes. I always use that USGenWeb site which you mentioned to begin to get info on various cities and counties that AMTRAK goes through on each route -- it is a pretty good site, but some states have much better coverage than others. (my guides cover the history, geology, and scenic attractions of each route)

As I said, this is off-topic, but your mention of the GenWeb sites inspired me to comment!! Good luck in your geneaology pursuits!! And I, like many others on this forum, DO hope that you and your big family will attempt another train trip in the near future!! Your kids will love it!!!

[This message has been edited by RRRICH (edited 02-10-2005).]
 

iowamomofsix
Member # 3695
 - posted
Wow! Thank you everyone for the tips! Dh wanted to fly to San Francisco and go down the coast from there. The BART info may just get us on the train. We'll see.

Thanks for the ABQ information. I would love to take the SWC to ABQ and fly the rest of the way.

RRRICH, are your guides online? I'd love to read them. I've become addicted to the Amtrack web site because I love geography and love maps. I like to look up station addresses, put them in Yahoo maps, and then look at the Smartfinder to see what is surrounding the station. However, without having been to these places myself, it's still hard to get an accurate picture of the environment around each station. I love reading the travel reports that are up on the web, and looking at photos.

David, I'd be willing to feature a page on the Omaha station, if a volunteer group like USGENWEB could be started. I wouldn't know how to link the site all together, but I do know how to code a page. Or, one of my kids could do it. We go to Omaha about once a month and I could start doing some research, even though I haven't been to the station yet. However, I am getting a pretty good grasp of the area.

Another question to the whole group, why don't I hear Amtrak commercials anymore, you know, "America is getting into training, training the Amtrak way." Have I had my head in the sand, or has Amtrak given up on ad campaigns? And if so, why?

Everyone have a great day,

Debbie
 

HeartlandExpress
Member # 3386
 - posted
Here is a cool web site that has most of the stations listed, with an arrow to go to the next station. You can go from station to station, just like being on the train.
http://snow.prohosting.com/usarail/omaha.htm

The link starts at Omaha. The website contains pictures, station code, address, trains that use the station, and distance between them.


 

TheBriz09
Member # 3166
 - posted
HeartlandExpress, I've been to that site before and I think it's a great and thorough listing of most of Amtrak's stations, pictures of them, and trains that pass through that. I don't want to speak for Debbie, but I think what she was referring to was a unified, single website that could offer information about safety, walking conditions, nearby hotels, rental cars, and anything else arriving families/people might need to know about the area around the station. The USA Rail Guide does an excellent job of cataloguing all of the stations with pictures, but I was thinking that perhaps maybe a little bit more could be done.

I was thinking about it today, and I think that maybe soon I will put up a poll asking people what they think about the idea and whether they would be willing to contribute... and perhaps if I get some time then I could work on putting together some concept pages.

Again, I might be one of a few, but I do think this is a really neat idea and I would love if anyone wanted to chat about the potential...
Email: David-Breisch@augustana.edu
AOL Instant Messenger: TheBriz09
 

RRRICH
Member # 1418
 - posted
Debbie - no, my RR guides are not on line. I have been thinking of organizing my own Web page one of these days with stuff like that on it for a long time, but I have yet not had the ambition to follow through with it, but maybe someday.....

I have "temporarily" (?) stopped producing my railroad guides, since now my main railroad project is to build my own model railroad empire!!
 

iowamomofsix
Member # 3695
 - posted
[b]I don't want to speak for Debbie, but I think what she was referring to was a unified, single website that could offer information about safety, walking conditions, nearby hotels, rental cars, and anything else arriving families/people might need to know about the area around the station.[b]

You're right. That's what I'm looking for. The web site was fun to look at, however, and the pictures were worth a 1000 words. It was fun to see some old haunts in California, like the Riverside station where we used to eat at the Spaghetti Factory, Y Mount in Provo, UT.

Thank you!

Debbie



 

HeartlandExpress
Member # 3386
 - posted
Check out this web site for the Texas Eagle. I think this is what Debbie has in mind. It also has the arrows to the next station, like the other web site.
http://www.texaseagle.com/stations/STL.htm
 
Pojon
Member # 3080
 - posted
Wake up! Amtrak is about to be murdered by Bush and the Republicans and you are talking petty nonsense. Write and call your congressmen and senators and Bush and tell him you want Amtrak to continue as a viable rail system with full funding! No kidding!
 
amtrakk_flyers
Member # 3738
 - posted
I agree..unless everyone calls and protest Amtrak will not be around after october!!!
 



Contact Us | Home Page

Powered by Infopop Corporation
UBB.classic™ 6.7.2




Copyright © 2007-2016 TrainWeb, Inc. Top of Page|TrainWeb|About Us|Advertise With Us|Contact Us