At least it looks like a done deal . The members of the MI legislature who were questioning the one-bid contract to buy new rail equipment are apparently convinced that the Talgo trainsets originally built for the Hiawatha route are "adequate" for the Chicago to Detroit/Pontiac route and are willing to accept the financial terms of the deal. MI Senate Transportation Committee Chairman John Pappageorge, R-Troy says:
quote:... what “raised red signals” was that Talgo was the sole bidder to supply the cars. The company happened to have newly built train sets sitting at an Amtrak facility in Beech Grove, Indiana, and Michigan needed to act quickly because federal funds were available.
“It was appropriate to look into it because that didn’t look right,” Pappageorge said. “Digging into it, we came to the conclusion that Talgo was the right answer — not a perfect one but adequate.”
As I've said before, I expect this equipment will provide extemely reliable service and that the overwhelming majority of passengers will be thrilled with the Talgos.
Posted by Gilbert B Norman (Member # 1541) on :
I'm all in favor, Mr. Vincent; just to get those trains generating revenue for somebody. However, as soon as the Michigan bi-level equipment makes the scene, find them somewhere else (you want 'em out there?).
I'm considering Mariinski Orchestra (St. Petersburg RU) concerts in Ann Arbor Jan 24 & 25 (have booked a hotel for those nights). If some cars are configured for Business Class and if there is any improvement in the abysmal performance of the Wolverine trains, I just might ride, as who knows what the "Lake Effect" weather can bring at that time of the year.
Posted by palmland (Member # 4344) on :
Best thing about the Talgos on a Vancouver trip was their Bistro car with good food and service. If that comes with it, then Michigan riders will be fortunate. Otherwise I'll take the superbly reconditioned 1960's vintage KCS/UP coaches used by NC DOT for their Piedmont service.
Posted by notelvis (Member # 3071) on :
For those of us who enjoy sitting comfortably on a train and gazing out the window, NC DOT's 1960's vintage coaches and the Cascades Talgos are the two best rides in the United States.
I cannot imagine the Talgos being more than a short-term novelty in Michigan (which is a shame). Given the absence of a dedicated midwestern maintenence facilty for them, I would imagine that the first 'unusual' defect will sideline them whether the midwestern bilevels are on the property by that time or not.
Posted by Vincent206 (Member # 15447) on :
It seems that the head of the Michigan DOT is being criticized for the purchase and refurbishment of rail cars for a proposed Detroit to Ann Arbor commuter rail line that won't begin operating until 2017 at the earliest. Those commuter cars have so far cost MI $9.5 million but they are currently sitting unused on a siding near Owosso MI. Meanwhile, the Chicago-Detroit-Pontiac Amtrak service, which serves over 480,000 riders a year, will continue to use old Amtrak rail cars until the MDOT has a chance to "...dive deeply into the business plan and financial aspects related to the maintenance facility, occupation and use, as well as the potential revenue." (of the Talgo trainsets).
Looks like 2 more sets have just become available for the Cascades service.